by michi » Sun Jan 03, 2010 10:41 pm
Yes, I have a few cases where I learned a rhythm early on and re-learned it again later.
Kluma (a Ghanaian rhythm) comes to mind. It starts out in typical 4/4 (quite fast) and then, in the middle of the rhythm, the soloist plays a 12/8 call and the rhythm switches to 12/8, maintaining the same 4/4 pulse, which creates a "slow down" effect. After a while, it goes back with a 4/4 call to the original rhythm. When I first learned this, the transitions baffled me completely. If found it very hard to feel the time signature change and constant pulse. About two years later, I re-learned that rhythm and found that, suddenly, I had no problem at all.
Another one is Tiriba. My teacher at the time introduced the first hand part without establishing the pulse first. Because the first accompaniment has equally-spaced slaps (each following 1/8th note after the pulse), I felt the pulse where the slaps are, instead of on the basses. It took me months of concentrated effort to re-program myself to feel it on the right side. Now, Tiriba comes easily, and I have no problem feeling it the right way.
Mendiani is yet another one. I first learned it from Aliou Sylla, maybe a year after I'd started drumming, and was completely baffled, both by the sangban and the solo holding pattern. Coming back to it about a year ago, things were much, much easier.
So, I find very much the same thing. Rhythms that I learned early on are not as solid. Not because they are further back in time, I think, but because I had less experience back then, and less vocabulary to relate each rhythm to. In turn, I think that means I committed those rhythms to memory in a different way than I commit rhythms to memory now. Back then, my understanding and depth of feeling a rhythm were much shallower. If I could analyse exactly how and where my brain stores each rhythm, I suspect that I would find that, for these early rhythms, there is a structural difference in the way they are stored. It's not until I return to an early rhythm and re-learn it that it gets moved into its proper place in my brain, alongside the other rhythms I learned later.
Cheers,
Michi.