by drumdesign22 » Fri Mar 11, 2011 3:45 pm
Hello djembefola! I haven't participated on this forum except for frequent readings of the articles about Music and Technical information (very helpful!), until I saw this thread. And even then, I am only posting because I feel very strongly about this subject. Not to say I wouldn't post more, but alas, I have very little time.
To abbyclark12: since you linked a .uk based site, I am taking this definition of fairtrade from the Fairtrade Foundation's Mission Statement (found at fairtrade.org.uk). It states:
"Fairtrade is about better prices, decent working conditions, local sustainability, and fair terms of trade for farmers and workers in the developing world"
There are many definitions, and even more organizations, which provide excellent information about this movement's history and development, so I hope this sparks some curiosity among this site's visitors to research the subject. It is absolutely pertinent, as African musical instruments are made almost entirely in the developing or third world, to our discussions here.
So, the original post, "Does anyone know/trust a company that is truly selling Fair trade Djembe's." is not referring to a transparent, trustworthy buying process from a business, but the ethics of the business itself.
Given x8's website, I assume they do very high volume sales, but since I wasn't able to find x8's mission statement, I did some research about drum suppliers in Indonesia. (This I assume is x8's main region/source of drums). I am sure the wholesale prices for Indonesian drums vary, the pricelist I was sent included a full size, “Pro African Djembe” for around $20USD each, not including shipping. Upon looking up a very similar drum on x8's site, where they are also listed as African djembes, the price is considerably more (List price: $500+ for 12"+ drum / Sale price: $300+).
I try to remain objective. The list or sale prices do not imply one way or another this company's business practices, unless you consider other information: wholesale price, the website's information about the products themselves (ie using the word "African" to describe something that is, to say the least, not African in region of origin, style, sound -- from the video clip on the site).
There is reason here to doubt that at $20 per drum, the Indonesian craftsman are receiving a fair portion for their labor; and that at $500 sale price, the proprietor's of x8 are contributing to better prices, sustainability, or fair terms for trade.
I hope that we remain a trustworthy and communicative community of artists and craftspeople, so that when misinformation is being passed on to customers, we can recognize it for what it is.